Tracing the history of medieval astronomy
We’re almost finished with chapter 6. All that’s left is to determine the position of the mean moon during one of the eclipses which will tell us the equation of anomaly at that point. To do so, we’ll add a few more points to the image we ended the last post with:
This past weekend was the summer solstice. Since the sun achieves its highest declination on this day, which is related to the obliquity of the ecliptic, this is a fundamental parameter that I try to observe the altitude on the solstice when possible. I did this back in 2018 using the solar angle dial from Book I of the Almagest. This time, I brought out the quadrant as I did for the autumnal equinox in 2018 as well.
Continue reading “Data: Summer Solstice Observation 6/20/2020”
We’ve come a long way in this book establishing a working model for solar motion. In fact, we’ve explored two models and derived a table that shows how far the sun would be away from its mean motion based on the mean position. However, at this point, everything has been done in terms of apogee and perigee.
In this chapter, we’ll be defining the “epoch“. What that means is that Ptolemy is going to pick a point in time, and define where the sun was on that date. Then, applying the tools we have developed in this book, we’ll be able to determine where the sun is at any other given date using the epoch as the starting point. For those that like things in a bit more mathy terms, it’s the location of the sun on the eccentre at time = 0, wherein Ptolemy will decide what that date is. To get there, we’ll first establish precise point on the eccentre at a known point in time, and then use the methods from this chapter to go backwards until we get to the chosen epoch date. Continue reading “Almagest Book III: On the Epoch of the Sun’s Mean Motion”
In the past couple Almagest posts, we’ve demonstrated that you can derive the equation of anomaly if you know the angle from apogee of either the mean or apparent motion using either the eccentric or epicyclic hypothesis1. Now, we’ll do the same using the angular distance from perigee again using 30º as our example. Continue reading “Almagest Book III: Equation of Anomaly from Perigee using Eccentric Hypothesis”
Our goal in this chapter will be to determine a systematic way to the equation of anomaly for the sun at 6º intervals from apogee (and perigee) along the eccentre. In this post, we’ll explore the method for finding this value from apogee for a single value of 30º. Continue reading “Almagest Book III: Equation of Anomaly from Apogee using Eccentric Hypothesis”
Now that we’ve laid out how the two hypotheses work and explored how they sometimes function similarly, it’s time to use one of them for the sun. But which one? Or do we need both?
For the sun, Ptolemy states that the sun has
a single anomaly, of such a kind that the time taken from least speed to mean shall always be greater than the time from mean speed to greatest.
In other words, the sun fits both models, but only requires one. Ptolemy chooses the eccentric model due to its simplicity.
But now it’s time to take the hypothesis from a simple toy, in which we’ve just shown the basic properties, and to start attaching hard numbers to it to make it a predictive model. To that end, Ptolemy states,
Our first task is to find the ratio of the eccentricity of the sun’s circle, that is, the ratio of which the distance between the center of the eccentre and the center of the ecliptic (located at the observer) bears to the radius of the eccentre.
Continue reading “Almagest Book III: On the Anomaly of the Sun – Basic Parameters”
So far in Book III, we’ve been looking at the mean sun1. However, the sun’s motion along the ecliptic is not even. In other words, its speed along the ecliptic is not constant. This poses a problem because, to Ptolemy:
the rearward displacements of the planets2 with respect to the heavens are, in every case, just like the motion of the universe in advance, by nature uniform and circular. That is to say, if we imagine the bodies or their circles being carried around by straight lines, in absolutely every case the straight line in question describes equal angles at the center of its revolution in equal times.
Here, Ptolemy states that he accepts uniform circular motion as true. So the question becomes how can something moving at a constant speed appear to have not constant speed? Continue reading “Almagest Book III: Hypotheses for Circular Motion – The Two Hypotheses”
To help us determine where the sun is on a given date, Ptolemy sets out a table to allow us to more quickly look this up instead of needing to calculate how far around the ecliptic the sun has moved. This table is very similar to another set of tables Ptolemy would produce later: The Handy Tables. However, there are some notable differences between this table and the Handy Tables. Continue reading “Almagest Book III: Table of the Mean Motion of the Sun”
Finally we’re at the end of Book II. In this final chapter1, Ptolemy presents a table in which a few of the calculations we’ve done in the past few chapters are repeated for all twelve of the zodiacal constellations, at different times before they reach the meridian, for seven different latitudes.
Computing this table must have been a massive undertaking. There’s close to 1,800 computed values in this table. I can’t even imagine the drudgery of having to compute these values so many times. It’s so large, I can’t even begin to reproduce it in this blog. Instead, I’ve made it into a Google Spreadsheet which can be found here.
First, let’s explore the structure.
Continue reading “Almagest Book II: Table of Zenith Distances and Ecliptic Angles”
In the last post, we started in on the angle between the ecliptic and an altitude circle, but only in an abstract manner, relating various things, but haven’t actually looked at how this angle would be found. Which is rather important because Ptolemy is about to put together a huge table of distances of the zenith from the ecliptic for all sorts of signs and latitudes. But to do so, we’ll need to do a bit more development of these ideas. So here’s a new diagram to get us going.
Here, we have the horizon, BED. The meridian is ABGD, and the ecliptic ZEH. We’ll put in the zenith (A) and nadir (G) and connect them with an altitude circle, AEG1. Although it’s not important at this precise moment, I’ve drawn it such that AEG has E at the point where the ecliptic is just rising. Continue reading “Almagest Book II: Angle Between Ecliptic And Altitude Circle – Calculations”