Posts

Posted on

Almagest Book V: The Difference at Syzygies – Maximum Lunar Anomaly

Syzygy is one of those words that has popped up very little in the Almagest so every time it does, I’m always thrown off a bit1. Especially when Ptolemy is going to spend an entire chapter discussing a topic that has scarcely even come up. But here we have Ptolemy spending the entirety of chapter $10$, to demonstrate that these modifications we’ve made to the lunar model have a negligible effect because he fears readers might think it does since

the centre of the epicycle does not always … stand exactly at the apogee at those times, but can be removed from the apogee by an arc [of the eccentre] of considerable size, because location precisely at the apogee occurs at the mean syzygies, whereas the determination of true conjunction and opposition requires taking the anomalies of both luminaries into account.

Continue reading “Almagest Book V: The Difference at Syzygies – Maximum Lunar Anomaly”

Posted on

Data: Stellar Quadrant Observations – 12/9/2020

Yesterday, the highs here in Three Rivers climbed into the 60’s. It’s December. This isn’t normal. But the weather was absolutely stunning and not even the sort that whips around to bone-chilling cold the next day as it was again in the 60’s today. This brief stability in the weather brought clear, calm skies, so despite it being a work night, I knew I needed to get out to observe.

Fortunately, with it getting dark so early, I could observe for several hours and still be home by a reasonable hour, even if I headed out to the further site I like observing at, Danville Conservation Area. And boy what a night it was! Continue reading “Data: Stellar Quadrant Observations – 12/9/2020”

Posted on

Almagest Book V: Calculation of the Lunar Position

It’s been awhile since I’ve done an Almagest post so quick recap. In Book IV, we worked out a first model for the moon, which was a simple epicycle model inclined to the plane of the sun’s sphere. In this book, Ptolemy showed us that this model was insufficient as the moon’s speed varies more than should predict and so we added an eccentric as well as having the center of the eccentre rotate around the observer. Finally, we introduced the concept of a “mean apogee” which is the position on the epicycle we’ll need to measure from in order to do calculations.

That’s been a lot, but with all of this completed, we should now be able to use it to calculate lunar positions which Ptolemy walks us through in this chapter. Unfortunately, he does this in the form of a generic prescription of steps instead of a concrete example. Fortunately, Toomer provides an example1 that I’ll use to supplement Ptolemy’s narration. Continue reading “Almagest Book V: Calculation of the Lunar Position”

Posted on

Data: Stellar Quadrant Observations – 11/6/2020

This is normally the part of the year where it gets difficult to go observing due to extremely cold temperatures at night. However, this week has seen daily highs in the mid 70’s and overnight lows in the mid 50’s. So with clear skies, I knew I needed to get out and observe.

Unfortunately, we’re at roughly a third quarter moon so it rose around 9:30 and was high enough to start being problematic by a little after 10:00. As such, I didn’t feel like making the long drive to Danville and just headed out to Broemmelsiek. The skies there continue to grow more and more light polluted so I was limited to pretty bright stars as it was. Continue reading “Data: Stellar Quadrant Observations – 11/6/2020”

Posted on

Almagest Book V: Constructing the Lunar Anomaly Table

In our last post, we showed how it is possible to determine the equation of anomaly by knowing the motion around the epicycle and the double elongation. This, combined with the position of the mean moon1 gives the true position of the moon. As usual, Ptolemy is going to give us a new table to make this relatively easy to look up. But before doing so, Ptolemy wants to explain what this table is going to look like. Continue reading “Almagest Book V: Constructing the Lunar Anomaly Table”

Posted on

Almagest Book V: Determining True Position of the Moon Geometrically From Periodic Motions

Now that we’ve revised our lunar model to include the position of the “mean apogee” from which we’ll measure motion around the epicycle, we need to discuss how we can use this to determine the true position of the moon.

As a general statement, we know how to do this: Take the position of the mean moon, determined by adding the motion since the beginning of the epoch, and add or subtract the equation of anomaly. The problem is that our revisions in this book mean the table for the lunar equation of anomaly we built in Book IV is no longer correct.

Instead, to determine the equation of anomaly, we’ll start with the motion around the epicycle1 and need to factor in the double elongation of the moon from the sun.

To see how to do so, let’s get started on a new diagram:

Continue reading “Almagest Book V: Determining True Position of the Moon Geometrically From Periodic Motions”

Posted on

Almagest Book V: Second Determination of Direction of Epicycle

In the last post, we followed along as Ptolemy determined that the position of “apogee” used for calculating the motion around the epicycle is not the continuation of the line from the center of the ecliptic or center of the eccentre through the center of the epicycle. Rather, motion should be measured from the “mean apogee” which is defined from a third point opposite the center of the ecliptic from the center of the eccentre.

Ptolemy doesn’t give a rigorous proof for this and instead relies on proof by example. So in that last post, we went through one example, but in this post, we’ll do a second one

in order to show that we get the same result at the opposite sides of the eccentre and epicycle.

Continue reading “Almagest Book V: Second Determination of Direction of Epicycle”

Posted on

Almagest Book V: The Direction of the Moon’s Epicycle

When we built the first lunar model, it was done using observations only at opposition, which is to say, during eclipses which only happen during the full phase. In the last few chapters, we looked at quadrature, which is to say, during first and third quarter moon and derived a second anomaly. But what happens if we consider the moon when it’s somewhere between those phases?

Ptolemy gives the answer:

[W]e find that the moon has a peculiar characteristic associated with the direction in which the epicycle points.

So what does that mean? Continue reading “Almagest Book V: The Direction of the Moon’s Epicycle”