Having reviewed Vogt’s work, Grasshoff now turns to dissecting Gundel’s. As a reminder, Gundel discovered a $15^{th}$ century set of hermetic writings that contained a list of stars that was dated to the time of Hipparchus, potentially making it the first direct evidence of a Hipparchan star catalog.
But what Gundel’s analysis lacked is any exploration of how this related to whether or not Ptolemy stole Hipparchus’ data. In this post, we’ll explore Grasshoff’s analysis of that topic. However, before doing so, Grasshoff works to ensure that we have the best possible understanding of the hermetic catalog before comparing the hermetic catalog to Ptolemy’s. Continue reading “Scholarly History of Commentary on Ptolemy’s Star Catalog: Grasshoff (1990) – Reviewing Gundel”